• Nominated for 10 Best Attorneys for Client Satisfaction in Mississippi for 2019 by American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys
  • Nominated American Society of Legal Advocates Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyers in the State of Mississippi for 2019
  • Nominated National Trial Lawyers Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyers in the State of Mississippi
  • Nominated National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys Top 10 Criminal Defense Attorneys in the State of Mississippi for 2018
  • Nominated American Society of Legal Advocates Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyers in the State of Mississippi for 2018
  • Nominated for 10 Best DUI Attorneys for Client Satisfaction in Mississippi for 2018 by American Institute of DUI/DWI Attorneys
  • Nominated for 10 Best Attorneys for Client Satisfaction in Mississippi for 2018 by American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys
  • Nominated for 10 Best DUI/DWI Attorneys by American Institute of DUI/DWI Attorneys for 2017 
  • Nominated for 10 Best Criminal Law Attorneys by American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys for 2017
  • Nominated for 10 Best Attorneys by American Institute of Family Law Attorneys for 2017
  • Nominated for Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyers by American Society of Legal Advocates for 2017
  • Nominated for Top 100 Criminal Defense Trial Lawyers by the The National Trial Lawyers for 2017
  • Nominated for 10 Best Criminal Law Attorneys by National Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys for 2017
  • Nominated for membership to Top American Lawyers in 2017
  • Nominated for membership of National Association of Personal Injury Lawyers in2017
  • Nominated for 10 Best DUI Attorneys for Client Satisfaction in Mississippi for 2016 by American Institute of DUI/DWI Attorneys
  • Awarded Superb "10" Rating by AVVO
  • Nominated for Top 10 Attorney Award by National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys for 2016
  • Top Attorney DUI on AVVO in 2016
  • Top Contributor DUI on AVVO in 2016
  • Nominated for Top 50 DUI Attorneys by National Advocacy for DUI Defense for 2016
  • Nominated for Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers for 2016
  • Nominated for 10 Best Attorneys in Mississippi for Client Satisfaction for 2016 by American Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys
  • Nominated for 10 Best Criminal Law Attorney for Mississippi for 2016 by American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys
  • Nominatedfor10 Best Family Law Attorneys by American Institute of Family Law Attorneys for 2016
  • Nominated for Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyers in America by The National Trial Lawyers
  • Nominated for Top 10 Attorney Award for 2015 in Mississippi by National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys
  • Nominated for 10 Best Client Satisfaction Award in 2014 by American Institute of DUI/DWI Attorneys
  • Nominated for Top 50 DUI Attorneys for 2014 in Mississippi by the National Advocacy for DUI Defense
  • Nominated for Top 10 Attorney Award for 2014 in Mississippi by National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys
  • Top Contributor DUI on AVVO in 2014
  • Top Contributor Criminal Defense on AVVO in 2014
  • Top Attorney DUI on AVVO in 2014
  • Top Attorney Criminal Defense on AVVO in 2014

Burned Will Claim Fails: What Mississippi Families Must Know

Facebook
LinkedIn
Reddit
X
WhatsApp
Print

What Happened

On November 10, 2026, the Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed a chancery court ruling in In the Matter of the Estate of Lamar DeLoach. According to reports, the appeal turned on one question: can a will that nobody can produce override a will that is already in the court file?

The decedent reportedly signed a will in July 2003. An attorney and the attorney’s secretary served as witnesses. The will named two of his cousins as co-executors, left a $100,000 gift to another individual, and left the rest of his property to the cousins. He died in January 2023. Within weeks, the cousins asked the chancery court to admit the 2003 will to probate, and the court did so in March 2023.

The decedent’s brother then filed a will contest. He alleged that the decedent had signed a newer will in 2012 that expressly cancelled the 2003 will, and that the decedent later destroyed the 2012 document. If that were true, he argued, no valid will would remain. Mississippi’s intestacy laws, the default inheritance rules that apply when there is no will, would then pass the entire estate to him as the sole heir.

The brother supported his claim with sworn statements from two people. One reportedly said he had advised the decedent to burn the 2012 will so it could not be reconstructed. He assumed it was burned but acknowledged he never saw it happen. The chancellor found these affidavits did not prove that a 2012 will had ever been properly signed and witnessed under Mississippi law. In March 2024, the chancellor granted summary judgment to the cousins. Summary judgment is a ruling without a trial, issued when there is no genuine dispute over the key facts.

The Court of Appeals agreed with the chancellor. It held that whether the 2012 document was destroyed did not matter, because no one proved it was ever valid. The 2003 will stands.

Who May Be Liable

Liability in a probate dispute looks different from liability in a car accident. Usually the fight is over who inherits, not who pays. Still, estate cases can involve parties who may be held legally responsible, depending on the facts.

No court found wrongdoing by anyone in the case described above. The dispute was about which document governed. In other Mississippi estate matters, the following parties could face claims:

  • Executors and administrators. These fiduciaries owe legal duties to the estate and its beneficiaries. If an executor mismanages assets, hides property, or engages in self-dealing, he or she could be held personally responsible.
  • People who hide or destroy a valid will. A testator (the person making the will) may lawfully revoke his or her own will. Someone else who allegedly conceals or destroys a valid will to change who inherits may face civil claims.
  • Beneficiaries accused of undue influence. A person who allegedly pressured a vulnerable relative into changing a will may have that gift set aside.
  • Drafting attorneys. In limited circumstances, a lawyer who fails to execute a will properly could face a malpractice claim. Nothing reported suggests the 2003 will in this case was prepared improperly; it was upheld.

Legal Theories That May Apply

  • Improper execution: A will that was not signed and witnessed as Mississippi law requires may be denied probate.
  • Revocation by a later writing: Under Miss. Code Ann. § 91-5-3, which the courts relied on here, a later will or written revocation must itself be properly made and executed to cancel an earlier will.
  • Revocation by physical act: A testator may revoke a will by destroying, canceling, or obliterating it, or by having it done in his or her presence.
  • Lost or destroyed will: A person seeking to probate a missing will generally must prove that it was validly executed and what it said.
  • Undue influence: A will may be invalidated if someone allegedly overpowered the testator’s free will.
  • Lack of testamentary capacity: A will may be challenged if the testator allegedly did not understand what he or she was signing.
  • Fraud or forgery: A forged or fraudulently obtained document has no legal effect.
  • Breach of fiduciary duty: Executors who allegedly misuse their position can be held accountable.
  • Intestate succession: If no valid will exists, Mississippi statutes decide who inherits.

Damages Victims May Recover

In estate litigation, recovery usually means getting what the law says you are entitled to. Depending on the facts, available relief may include:

  • Your rightful inheritance share under a valid will or under intestacy laws.
  • Return of estate assets that were allegedly taken, hidden, or wasted.
  • Surcharge against a fiduciary. This is a court order requiring an executor to repay losses caused by a breach of duty.
  • Removal of an executor or administrator who is not acting properly.
  • Attorney’s fees and costs in certain circumstances, at the court’s discretion.
  • Compensatory damages where fraud or other wrongful conduct is proven.
  • Punitive damages in rare cases. Mississippi’s punitive damages statute, Miss. Code Ann. § 11-1-65, requires clear and convincing evidence of actual malice, gross negligence, or actual fraud.

Evidence That Strengthens a Case

This case shows how important firsthand proof is. An assumption that a will was burned was not enough. Evidence that can matter includes:

  • The original signed will and the names of its attesting witnesses.
  • Testimony from the witnesses who actually watched the will being signed.
  • The drafting attorney’s file, including notes, drafts, billing records, and retained copies.
  • Firsthand witnesses to any destruction or revocation, rather than secondhand accounts.
  • Medical records bearing on the testator’s mental condition when the will was signed.
  • Financial records showing transfers, account changes, or missing assets.
  • Letters, emails, and texts in which the testator discussed his or her plans.
  • Safe deposit box and storage records showing where the original was kept.

What to Do Next

If you believe a loved one’s wishes are not being honored, take these careful steps:

  1. Secure documents. Locate any wills, copies, or drafts, and do not mark or alter them.
  2. Write down what you know while memories are fresh, including who saw what and when.
  3. Watch the deadlines. Mississippi generally allows a will contest within two years after a will is probated, but formal notice can shorten that window considerably.
  4. Do not sign waivers or accept distributions before you understand your rights.
  5. Communicate carefully with executors and other relatives. Your statements may later become evidence.
  6. Plan your own estate properly. Sign your will with the required formalities. Revoke an old will formally. Tell your executor where the original is kept.

If you or a loved one is facing a disputed will, a missing estate plan, or questions about an executor’s conduct, William Wayne Housley, Attorney at Law, can help you understand where you stand. We offer a thoughtful, confidential review of your situation. Learn more at https://housleylaw.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I challenge a will in Mississippi if I think a newer one existed?

Yes. An interested person may generally contest a will in Mississippi. However, you will likely need to prove that the newer will was properly signed and witnessed, not just that someone believes it existed. As the recent appeals ruling shows, a later document that cannot be proven valid may have no effect on an earlier will.

How long do I have to contest a will in Mississippi?

Mississippi law generally allows a will contest within two years after the will is admitted to probate. If the will was probated with formal notice to you, your window may be much shorter or may already have closed. Because these deadlines can be strict, it is wise to speak with an attorney promptly.

What happens if someone destroyed my relative’s will?

A testator may lawfully revoke his or her own will by destroying it. If someone else allegedly destroyed or hid a valid will without the testator’s direction, the will may still be proven through copies and witness testimony. That person could also face civil claims.

Is a copy of a will good enough in Mississippi?

Possibly, but it is difficult. Courts typically require proof that the original was properly executed and evidence of its contents. If the original was last in the testator’s possession and cannot be found, the court may presume he or she revoked it, and that presumption may need to be overcome.

Who inherits if there is no valid will in Mississippi?

Mississippi’s intestacy statutes set the order. A spouse and children generally come first. If there are none, the estate usually passes to other close relatives, such as parents and siblings. The exact outcome depends on which family members survive the decedent.

Can a handwritten will be valid in Mississippi?

Yes. Mississippi recognizes holographic wills, which must be written entirely in the testator’s own handwriting and signed by him or her. Such wills do not require attesting witnesses, but disputes over handwriting and intent are common. A formally witnessed will is generally easier to defend.

Who has to prove their case in a will dispute?

The party challenging an existing will, or claiming that a later will revoked it, generally carries the burden of proof. Assumptions and secondhand accounts may not be enough to meet that burden. Strong, firsthand evidence is usually essential.

Original reporting: timesofindia.indiatimes.com.


Legal Services